Which Wingback pen? Fountain vs Journeyman vs Mechanical
Three pens, three quite different ways of writing. Here's how to choose between the Wingback Fountain Pen, Journeyman and Mechanical Pen, based on how you like to write and where you'll carry it.
At a glance
- There's no single best Wingback pen; it comes down to how you like to write and where you carry it.
- Choose the Fountain Pen for expressive nib writing and a proper daily ritual, in CNC-machined steel or brass.
- Choose the Journeyman for an easy, no-fuss everyday pen that simply works.
- Choose the Mechanical Pen for pocket-friendly toughness; it takes any standard G2 refill, including a pressurised Fisher cartridge that writes almost anywhere.
If you're trying to work out which Wingback pen is right for you, the quickest way to decide is to think less about specifications and more about how you actually like to write, and where the pen will live day to day. All three are forged to last and carry our lifetime guarantee, so this isn't about better or worse. It's about matching the pen to your hand, your desk and your pocket. Once you've chosen your pen, it's worth pairing it with a refillable notebook you keep for life. An engraved pen also makes one of the best personalised gifts for men.
Here's how the three compare at a glance, then a little more on each so you can pick with confidence.
| Pen | Writing style | Best for | Material & make |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fountain Pen | Nib and liquid ink, expressive line | The ritual of writing at a desk | 303 stainless steel or brass, CNC machined in England |
| Journeyman Pen | Smooth, everyday writing | An easy, no-fuss daily companion | Machined metal, built to last |
| Mechanical Pen | Any G2 refill, from a smooth ballpoint to a pressurised Fisher | Pockets, travel and rough weather | Machined metal, no clip, takes any G2 refill |
The Fountain Pen: for people who love the act of writing
If putting pen to paper is something you genuinely enjoy, and you want each line to have a bit of character to it, the Fountain Pen is the one. It's fitted with a Bock iridium nib and lays down proper liquid ink, which gives your handwriting that soft, expressive quality a ballpoint never quite manages.
It's CNC machined in England and comes in a few distinct finishes, and this is where personal taste really comes into it. The warm, golden brass version is the most characterful of the lot; brass oxidises and reacts with the natural oils in your skin, so it darkens and develops a patina that makes it unmistakably yours. If you'd rather it stay looking much as it did on day one, the harder-wearing steel finishes such as the iridescent Jet Fuel hold their look beautifully. There's no wrong answer here, just the one you'll reach for. To weigh brass, steel, titanium and Black Steel side by side, our guide to Wingback metal finishes explains how each one ages and wears.
It takes a 38mm international standard ink cartridge (a pack of Diamine ink cartridges, made in Liverpool since 1864, is a lovely place to start), and if you fancy a wider range of colours you can also fill the barrel directly using the eyedropper technique. If you do that, stick to a neutral ink with a pH close to 7.
A brass pen doesn't stay pristine, it becomes a record of every note you've ever written with it.
Who should skip it?
Fountain pens ask a little more of you. They prefer to be stored nib-up, they don't love being left unused for months, and they're happiest with decent paper. If that sounds like more attention than you want to give a pen, one of the other two will suit you better.
The Journeyman Pen: the easy everyday choice
The Journeyman is the pen for people who just want something well made that writes smoothly and never makes a fuss. It's the sort of pen you leave in a notebook, a jacket or a bag and simply use, without thinking about nibs, ink or storage. If you write in short bursts through the day, meetings, lists, the odd card, and you want reliability above ritual, this is a very easy pen to live with.
Like everything we make, it's built to be repaired and kept rather than replaced, which is really the whole point of choosing a considered pen over a disposable one. If that idea resonates, our thoughts on buying less and buying better are worth a read.
The Mechanical Pen: made for pockets and rough weather
The Mechanical Pen is the toughest of the three and the one we'd steer you towards if your pen lives in a pocket, a toolbag or a rucksack rather than on a desk. It takes any standard G2 refill and comes fitted with a Schmidt easyFlow 9000. For rough conditions, fit a Fisher cartridge, a pressurised refill that keeps writing upside down, in the cold, on damp paper and at altitude; it fits with its plastic extender trimmed by 0.5 mm. Our G2 refill guide covers the rest.
We put a lot of thought into how it works and feels in the hand; if you're curious about the design, we wrote about the making of it in Designs: The Mechanical Pen.
A note on refills
The Mechanical Pen and the Journeyman Pen take the same standard G2 refill, so one spare covers both. The Fountain Pen takes international standard ink cartridges. The original Mechanical Pen (117.5 mm long) takes the Fisher cartridge as it comes.
So, which Wingback pen should you choose?
Choose the Fountain Pen if you love the ritual of writing and want a line with character, and pick your finish on looks alone; the brass ages beautifully, the steel finishes stay sharp. Choose the Journeyman if you want a handsome, dependable pen that asks nothing of you. Choose the Mechanical Pen if it's going in a pocket and needs to work wherever you are. Whichever you land on, it's made by hand to be used for a very long time. And if a pen is just one part of your everyday carry, our guide to choosing the right Wingback wallet is a natural next read.
Leave a comment